The Evening Wrap: How will migrants get food without ration cards, asks SC

The Hindu Newsletter - The biggest news stories from today

The Evening Wrap Friday | 11 June, 2021

Welcome to the Evening Wrap newsletter, your guide to the day's biggest stories with concise analysis from The Hindu.

Open in browser

More newsletters

How will migrants get food without ration cards, asks Supreme Court
The Supreme Court on Friday asked the Centre how it intended to deliver food to crores of migrant labourers who have no ration cards. "How will food reach migrant labourers without ration cards?" a Bench of Justices Ashok Bhushan and M.R. Shah addressed Solicitor General Tushar Mehta and Additional Solicitor General Aishwarya Bhati, for the Centre. The court said the schemes rolled out so far seemed to cover only ration card holders. Bhati explained that the Centre had kept its best foot forward with the Pradhan Mantri Garib Kalyan Anna Yojana, which covers 80 crore poor identified as beneficiaries under the National Food Security Act. The scheme provides 5 kg of free food grains to every person for May and June. It intends to help the poor tide over the economic disruptions caused by the pandemic. Eight lakh metric tonnes of food grains have already been given, she added. "No doubt you [the Centre] are providing food… No doubt some migrant labourers have ration cards… But we are only bothered about those who do not have them. We want to know about your mechanism to identify and provide food for people who do not have ration cards…" Justice Bhushan addressed the government side. Bhati said the Centre was only in charge of making available or procuring food grains. The States had to distribute the food within their territories. The law officer said the Centre was ready to give the States whatever they wanted. Senior advocate Dushyant Dave, who appeared for some activists along with advocate Prashant Bhushan, said the "Centre was leaving them [the poor without ration cards] to the mercy of the States." "Those without ration cards cannot be allowed to die… The economic situation is far more dire now," Dave said. Mehta strongly objected to Mr. Dave's submissions, saying he was "dramatising" the issue. In the previous hearing, Bhushan had submitted that the Centre had last year recorded 8 crore migrant workers without ration cards. The States had identified 2.8 crore of them. At this point, the court pulled up the government for delaying the completion of a national database to identify and register migrant workers. The creation of the database portal has remained a non-starter for months now. The government said the delay had something to do with the "software". The database would have helped the Centre work in tandem with State governments to identify migrant labourers and provide them timely welfare during the pandemic. The government side said the database would be ready in the next three or four months. "Why do you need three or four months? You are only preparing a database portal," Justice Bhushan asked. Bhati explained that the portal would be an "end-to-end" one, which would not only function as a database but also help in tracking and monitoring benefits meant for migrant labourers. Mukul Roy and his son return to Trinamool Nearly a month after the BJP suffered a big defeat in the West Bengal Assembly polls, its vice president Mukul Roy on Friday returned to the Trinamool Congress (TMC). Roy (67), one of the founding members of the TMC, had shifted to the BJP in November 2017. TMC supremo and Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee Roy, now a BJP MLA from Krishnanagar Uttar, held a joint press conference after a two-hour meeting. Roy described Banerjee "as a leader of the entire country". He said he was feeling relieved after quitting the BJP. "In the present circumstances, no one can stay in the BJP in Bengal," he stated. Banerjee in turn described Roy as an "old family member" and added that "old is always gold". "Our party is already a strong party. Mukul is an old family member. He was pressured by agencies. I think this decision will provide him mental relief. His health was deteriorating also." His defection from the BJP indicated that more people from the BJP would join the TMC, she said. Those who defected from the party just before the elections and attacked it in sharp language would not be allowed to join it again. "Only those who are gentle, we will consider them," she observed. Roy's son and former MLA Subhrangshu Roy also followed his father's footsteps to return to the TMC. The speculation of Mukul Roy's return to the TMC gained momentum after Banerjee visited a city hospital to inquire about the health of his wife last week. Prime Minister Narendra Modi too called up Roy. The veteran politician was reportedly upset for not being given much importance during the 2021 Assembly polls, where Nandigram MLA Suvendu Adhikari emerged as the important face of the BJP. Roy had played a crucial role in the 2019 Lok Sabha polls when the BJP won 18 out of the 42 seats. Supreme Court refuses to hear Mumbai Police ex-chief's plea seeking transfer of inquiries The Supreme Court on Friday told former Mumbai Police chief Param Bir Singh that "people who live in glass houses should not throw stones at others" while refusing to entertain his plea seeking the transfer of the inquiries/case against him outside Maharshtra to be investigated by an independent agency. He has alleged that the State government is trying to "frame" him for levelling corruption charges against Shiv Sena leader Anil Deshmukh, who had to resign as Home Minister. Along with Singh's petition, the Bench of Justices Hemant Gupta and V. Ramasubramanian was also considering an application filed by Mumbai Police Inspector Bhimraj Rohidas Ghadge, who accused Singh, in turn, of corruption and vindictiveness. Ghadge, represented by senior advocate S.B. Talekar and advocate Vipin Nair, accused his former boss of having tried to "silence" him by framing fake cases against him. "It is commonly said that people who live in glass houses should not throw stones at others," Justice Gupta told senior advocate Mahesh Jethmalani, appearing for Singh. Jethmalani raised an objection to the comment, saying it was a "prejudicial statement" and amounted to "pre-judging" the case. The court, however, was not impressed. Singh alleged that the government had instituted departmental inquiries against him as an act of reprisal for his complaint about Deshmukh. Solicitor General Tushar Mehta was present in court for the CBI. However, the court saw it differently. "You [Singh] are part of the Maharashtra IPS cadre. You have served the State for 30 years, and now you don't have confidence in your own State. It is shocking… It is a shocking allegation you are making," Justice Gupta addressed Jethmalani. The senior lawyer said there were other police officers in Maharashtra who, like his client, had been "victimised" by the State government. He claimed that the Maharashtra DGP had approached him as a "mentor" to give up on his complaint. "If a person in the rank of DGP can be pressurised, then there is nobody left… Please do not make these make-believe stories," Justice Gupta told Jethmalani. The court said it cannot possibly intervene and stay the registration of FIR against Singh. "Mr. Jethmalani, you are an experienced criminal lawyer. How can there be a blanket stay by a court on the power of the police to register an FIR against any person" Justice Gupta asked. Not in touch with BJP, says Sachin Pilot While former Rajasthan Congress chief Sachin Pilot on Friday dismissed reports of BJP leaders being in touch with him, the All India Congress Committee (AICC) in-charge for Rajasthan Ajay Maken asserted that there would soon be a cabinet expansion of the Ashok Gehlot-led government. The AICC general secretary also played down reports of Pilot being 'angry' with the party. "When I am here, how is it possible that views of the MLAs are not heard? We are taking future steps after talking to everyone and ascertaining their views. The vacant posts that are there, be they in the Cabinet or the Boards of Commissions, appointments will happen very soon," Maken said on the sidelines of a symbolic protest against the continuous fuel price hike. On his part, Pilot took part in a protest against fuel hike in Jaipur and categorically rejected the claims that Congress-turned-BJP leader Rita Bahuguna Joshi had spoken to him. "I also heard that Rita Bahuguna Joshi had spoken to Sachin. Maybe she spoke to Sachin Tendulkar. She doesn't have the courage to speak to me," Pilot quipped to reporters at the protest venue. Amid speculation that the former Rajasthan Deputy Chief Minister could be the next to exit from the Congress after Jitin Prasada, Maken said he was in regular touch with Pilot. "I speak to him regularly [Pilot]. If he was angry, then would he have spoken to me," Maken said. However, a source close to Pilot told The Hindu that the Pilot camp is not happy that the Congress High Command has not been able to 'deliver' on the promises made to him and his supporters even after 10 months. After his unsuccessful revolt against Gehlot, the Congress had removed Pilot both from the post of the Pradesh Congress Committee (PCC) chief as well as Deputy Chief Minister. The MLAs and the ministers who support him were also stripped of all official positions. Last August, the AICC had formed a three-member committee with Congress general secretary (organisation), K.C. Venugopal, Maken and Ahmed Patel to look into Pilot's grievances. However, the panel made little progress due to Patel's prolonged hospitalisation due to Covid-19 and his subsequent death. USFDA rejection of Covaxin has no impact on its use in India, says Centre The rejection by the USFDA (United States Food and Drug Administration) of the emergency use application of Bharat Biotech's Covaxin has no impact on the policies in India, NITI Aayog member (Health) Dr. V.K. Paul said at a Union Health Ministry press conference on Friday. "Every country has its parameter for approval of vaccinations for its population despite the world sharing a common scientific framework for approval. India also follows its own regulatory process for approval that is tailor-made for our population. It's their decision, it should be respected. Our regulator has endorsed this vaccine and there is no impact on use of Covaxin in our national programme,'' he stated, noting that Covaxin phase-3 clinical trial data would be published in the next 7-8 days. "We expect that the Covaxin manufacturers will be able to comply with the regulators' requirement. Our regulator has approved this vaccine. We have enough data on safety and efficacy,'' he asserted. With the Health Ministry saying on Friday that India was now showing indications of an improving Covid-19 scenario, Dr. Paul said the Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) was preparing for a national survey. "The ICMR will begin work for next sero survey this month. But if we want to protect our geographies, we won't have to depend on national sero survey alone, we'll have to encourage States for sero surveys too,'' he observed. Covid watch: Numbers and Developments The number of reported coronavirus cases from India stood at 2,93,38,118 at the time of publishing this newsletter, with the death toll at 3,64,515. Extending the ongoing Covid-19 lockdown till 6 a.m. of June 21, the Tamil Nadu government on Friday announced fresh relaxations in 27 districts including Chennai. In Brief: The Economic Offences Wing of the State Police has arrested Ravi Parthasarathy, 69, former chairman of the IL&FS Group, in connection with the alleged cheating of a Chennai-based private limited company to the tune of ₹200 crore through its subsidiary IL&FS Transportation Networks India Limited (ITNL), Mumbai. Parthasarathy was arrested by the police in Mumbai and brought to the city on Thursday. He was produced before the Special Court for cases under the Tamil Nadu Protection of Interests of Depositors (TNPID) Act and remanded to judicial custody for 15 days. He has been lodged in the Saidapet sub-jail. The U.S. Senate has approved the historic nomination of Pakistani-American Zahid Quraishi to the District Court in New Jersey, making him the first Muslim federal judge in the country's history. The Senate voted 81-16 on Thursday to confirm Quraishi, 46. As many as 34 Republicans joined the Democrats in confirming the first-ever Muslim-American as a federal judge. Currently, a magistrate judge for the District of New Jersey, Quraishi would now make history when he will be sworn in as the Judge of the U.S. District Court of New Jersey. Evening Wrap will return tomorrow.

Today's Top Picks

Fall in e-waste generation in poor countries shows growing digital divide, report says In photos: Rover leaves 'China's imprint' on Mars Vijay's 'Master' tops IMDb list of most popular Indian films in 2021 'Those Who Wish Me Dead' movie review: Angelina Jolie shines in fiery thriller

Copyright @ 2021, THG PUBLISHING PVT LTD.

If you are facing any trouble in viewing this newsletter, please try here

If you do not wish to receive such emails go here